Rory versus Scoble - Full Contact Blogging.

by JoeStagner 3/20/2007 5:03:45 PM

Rory and (Robert) Scoble are at war.

In my time at Microsoft I’ve gotten to know both of them. I “lovingly” tell you they’re both egomaniacs (as am I!)

Rory and I have have found much to argue about. I think because we are so different, but many mutual acquaintances say it’s because we are alike apart from the decades that separate us in age.

Scoble has taken to bashing Microsoft these days and Rory is taking him to the woodshed for it. Robert, your opinions have made you famous, but when some one with comparatively little business experience (and I don’t mean that as an insult, but even using my own experiences as a comparative benchmark, I believe this is accurate), leaves a company and them makes a big deal about what a mess your “old” company is and how you have the answers…….

Well, it reads like pure sensationalism intended only to place your non-profitable company on the media coattails of your former employer.

Robert deserves credit for his accomplishments while at Microsoft, but his contentions about “discoveries” are, shall I say, “creative writing”, many of us were doing what he takes credit for inventing back then. He just had the luxury of getting allot of funding.

http://scobleizer.com Would likely have a very small fraction of it’s readership had he not had the luxury of Microsoft’s budget and properties to promote it, and in my opinion, http://scobleizer.com declines steadily in relevance since his departure from Microsoft.

While Rory (tung in cheek) refers to himself as the Smartest Man on the Planet, he doesn’t take himself so seriously. In fact, Rory doesn’t misrepresent himself as a business guru.

In the years that I’ve known him, I’ve often found Rory to be infuriating, but I have always found him to be honest.

Rory’s work on C9 is comedy, documentary, entertainment, news even.

I personally appreciate Rory’s humility in the grand scheme of things relative to Microsoft and the world of Technical Business.

I also admire him for taking pride in the company that has given him opportunities and for taking issue with Roberts insults.

I think Robert could bite the hand the fed him with a little more grace, whatever we aren’t perfect at, nobody was listening to Scoble until Microsoft took him public.

Be the first to rate this post

  • Currently 0/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Tags:

Related posts

Comments

3/20/2007 6:57:34 PM

A little historical revisionism. I had more than 1,000 readers a day on my blog BEFORE joining Microsoft and was already on top of the Technorati blog list of millions of blogs back then.

Also, it'd be nice to see a little balance. Do a Google search for "Demo of the Year" and you'll find #1 post is something nice I said about Microsoft.

Or, watch these videos I just posted today about Microsoft Research. scobleizer.com/.../

Robert Scoble

3/20/2007 9:31:14 PM

I'm supprised Robert that you seem to be having such a visceral reaction to a little diagreement from your readership.

You know it goes with the territory.

Your post proved my point though. 1000 readers is alot? Hell, as bloggers go I'm nobody, but on days that I post I have nearly 1000 readers.

I'm not saying you don't deserve credit for your work and innovations while you were at Microsoft, just that you would not likely have done much of it had you not been HERE when you did it.

I guess putting faith in YOU was the one other thing you would agree we've done right this decade.

As for ballance - agree, for my part that ballance comes in that I have been (and am today) a reader of your writings.

I've agreed with much of what you have written over the years, pro and con - I don't agree with much of your recent writing - that seems ballanced to me.

Speaking of ballance....

Since you've become pretty anti-Microsoft recentlhy, I'm forced to question?

Have you sudenly had this epiphany that Microsoft is incompetent ?

Did you think this while you worked here, but decline to share the negativity because your sallary trumped "journalistic integrity"?

Or is there some other motivation that we're left to speculate on?

For me, it's not that you have an uncomplementary opinion so much as the way you agrandise your opinion.

Howard Stern is a noisy opinionated guy, but I don't make decisions based on what he says on his show.

Your experience has always lead me to view your writing as information rather than entertainment and - for me - recent writing are leaning away from that.

Joe Stagner

3/21/2007 3:42:07 AM

You bust on Scoble and praise Rory, but you link Scoble three times and Rory not once. More egregious, you provide no links to their "war" posts. Come on--every time you fail to link to what you're talking about God kills a lazy person. Please, think of the lazies.

McGurk

3/21/2007 4:51:32 AM

Points for humor but the first word of the post is a hyperlink to Rory's blog.

:0)

Joe Stagner

3/21/2007 4:57:45 AM

I am no fanboy, but how can you say that Scoble never bashed Microsoft while he was an employee? That is one of the reasons I started reading Scobleizer when he worked for MS: it was an employee openly saying what he saw was wrong with his employer. I think both in the past and in the present, Robert has always been honest enough to say when MS does well and when it sucks. And one step better, he has been honest enough to say when he himself sucks.

Jason

3/21/2007 4:50:55 PM

Joe, I have to say I agree. I have tried to keep up with Robert and his blog and new thing. But honestly it just seems so scattered that I just gave up. You are so on point about how he benfited from MSFT giving him an advantage. These are exactly the thoughts I have had about his productions since he left.
I know it is pretty cool to be able to report about a wide variety of things and I can see this as a natural pursuit by any journalist. But he did such a good job inside MSFT, now I just think his stuff is boring. Sorry Robert, just my HO.

Chris Love

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.3.0.0
Theme by Mads Kristensen

About your host.

Name of author Joe Stagner
?????

E-mail me Send mail

Calendar

<<  October 2008  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
293012345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829303112
3456789

View posts in large calendar

Pages

Recent comments

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in anyway.

© Copyright 2008

Sign in